When Should You Switch to a 3PL?

Most brands wait too long

Most ecommerce brands start out packing orders themselves. That makes sense early on: you learn your customers, your packaging and what breaks in transit. The trouble is that the switch to outsourcing usually happens late, after a missed peak season or a run of bad reviews, rather than when the numbers first said it was time.

At Plan A Logistics we’ve shipped more than 2 million ecommerce orders to Australians in the last 12 months. That’s over 5,000 orders leaving our warehouse every day, with 99.8% of them fulfilled on time. Working at that scale, we see the same warning signs come up again and again in brands that are ready to outsource. They fall into four groups: order volume, warehouse space, staff and day-to-day bottlenecks.

Already with a 3PL? You’re not alone. Around 90% of the brands we onboard are moving from another provider, most often because orders were leaving too slowly or customer service wasn’t up to scratch. Most of the signs below apply to you too, and there’s a section further down on when it’s time to change providers.

If two or more of the sections below sound familiar, it’s worth getting a quote now, before your next busy period rather than in the middle of it.

1. Order volume: when packing becomes a job

There’s no official threshold, but once you’re shipping a few hundred orders a week, someone in your business is spending most of their day picking, packing and booking couriers, whether or not that’s in their job description. At Plan A Logistics, we work with brands shipping a minimum of 500 orders a week.

A more useful test than raw volume is your real cost per order. Add up packaging, postage, wages (including your own time), rent for the space and the cost of fixing mistakes. Divide that by the orders you shipped last month. Most brands have never done this sum, and the answer is usually higher than they expect. Put it next to a 3PL quote and the decision often makes itself.

Volume is also about the orders you’re not taking. If you’ve held back on a Black Friday promotion, a new marketplace or a wholesale account because you weren’t sure you could ship the extra orders, your fulfilment setup is already capping your growth.

Then there are the peaks. A 3PL that ships thousands of orders a day can absorb your Black Friday spike without you hiring, training or paying overtime.

Rack of dresses on hangers, the kind of growing fashion stock that outgrows a storeroom before brands move to a 3PL warehouse

2. Warehouse space: the lease question

Space usually runs out gradually. First the storeroom fills, then the corner of the office, then stock ends up split across two locations and nobody’s quite sure what’s where. Picking slows down and stock counts stop matching your system.

At that point most brands face a choice: sign a bigger lease, or outsource. A bigger warehouse feels like progress, but it comes with a multi-year commitment, racking, equipment, insurance and the people to run it. You also end up paying for peak-season space in the middle of winter.

Two other signs are easy to miss. One is turning down a better unit price on a larger production run because you had nowhere to store it. The other is overselling, or finding dead stock months too late, because your inventory records have drifted.

With a 3PL you pay for the space you actually use, and a proper warehouse management system tracks every unit.

3. Staff: when everyone is packing

Picture a Monday morning at a growing brand. The customer service lead is behind on emails because she spent the first two hours packing weekend orders. The founder is printing labels between supplier calls. And the one person who really understands the dispatch process is on leave next week.

That’s the staffing problem in a nutshell. Fulfilment spreads across people who were hired to do something else, and it depends on one or two people who can’t be replaced at short notice.

Hiring a dedicated warehouse team solves part of this, but it adds recruitment, rostering, leave cover, WHS obligations and a crew of casuals to train every peak. Those costs are high, and stay put in a quiet month.

The simplest test: if you can’t take a week off without orders backing up, it’s time.

4. Bottlenecks: when customers notice

Sooner or later, fulfilment problems show up in your reviews: parcels that leave days late, wrong items in the box, refunds that drag on. Below are the service levels we run to at Plan A Logistics. If your current setup can’t get close, your customers are probably feeling the difference.

AreaPlan A Logistics benchmark
On-time fulfilment99.8% of orders fulfilled on time
DispatchEcommerce orders received before 11am ship the same day. Later orders ship same day where possible, otherwise the next business day.
Pack time3.5 hours on average, from receiving an order to having it packed
Wholesale and store replenishmentFulfilled within 24 hours
ReturnsProcessed in under 1 day

Some bottlenecks cost you money without customers ever seeing them. Paying for an entire warehouse team and warehouse rent is one. If you are already with a 3PL, slow turnaround times or incorrect order fulfilment is another. So is having no real-time view of stock levels, which is how overselling happens.

Already with a 3PL? When to change providers

Outsourcing isn’t a one-off decision. Around 90% of the brands that come to Plan A Logistics are moving from another 3PL, and their reasons are remarkably consistent: orders take too long to leave the warehouse, and when something goes wrong, it’s hard to get a fast, helpful answer.

It may be time to look elsewhere if:

  • “Same-day dispatch” regularly turns into two or three days, especially around peak season.
  • Picking errors are creeping up, and you hear about them from customers before your 3PL tells you.
  • You chase updates by email for days instead of getting a clear answer from someone who knows your account.
  • Your business feels too small to be a priority for them.

Changing 3PLs is less disruptive than most brands fear. A well-planned move covers channel integration, stock transfer and testing before your first order ships from the new warehouse, so your customers should notice only one thing: faster delivery.

Quick check: are you ready for a 3PL?

Tick each statement that applies to your business. If you tick three or more, outsourcing fulfilment is worth exploring now.

When a 3PL might not be right (yet)

Outsourcing isn’t the right move for every business at every stage. It may be worth waiting if you’re shipping only a handful of orders a week, your products need hands-on customisation for each order, or you’re still testing product-market fit and your range changes constantly.

Even then, it pays to plan ahead. Moving to a 3PL takes a few weeks of onboarding, so the best time to start talking to providers is before you hit breaking point, not during your busiest month.

Why brands switch to Plan A Logistics

Plan A Logistics handles storage, pick and pack, dispatch and returns for Australian ecommerce and wholesale brands. In the last 12 months that added up to more than 2 million ecommerce orders, so a jump from 50 orders a day to 500 doesn’t stretch us.

The difference shows up quickly. Here’s what one client told us only a short time after making the move:

We highly recommend Plan A Logistics as a 3PL solution. From day one, their team has been incredibly accommodating and truly invested in the success of our business. Despite only working with Plan A for a short period of time, they already feel like an extension of our team.

We’re grateful for the partnership we’ve built and look forward to continuing to grow alongside them. A fantastic team and a logistics partner we would recommend!

Georgette, One Mile

When you partner with us, you get:

  • 99.8% of orders fulfilled on time
  • Same-day dispatch for ecommerce orders received before 11am
  • Storage that grows and shrinks with your inventory and peak seasons
  • Integrations with your sales channels, so orders flow straight to our warehouse
  • Competitive shipping rates through our carrier partners
  • A dedicated contact to guide you through onboarding

Thinking about outsourcing? Talk to the Plan A Logistics team for a no-obligation fulfilment quote. Tell us your order volumes and products, and we’ll show you what your costs and dispatch times would look like with us.

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch to Plan A Logistics from my current 3PL?

Yes, and most of our clients have done exactly that: around 90% come to us from another 3PL. We plan the move with you, from connecting your sales channels to transferring your stock, so your orders keep shipping throughout the changeover.

How long does it take to switch to a 3PL?

Most moves take a few weeks, covering system integration, stock transfer and testing. Planning ahead avoids switching during a peak period.

When is the best time to switch 3PLs?

Outside your busiest period. For most Australian ecommerce brands, that means avoiding October to December, when Click Frenzy, Black Friday and Christmas orders peak. Start talking to new providers a couple of months before you want to go live, so there’s time to plan the move properly.

Will my customers notice the switch?

They shouldn’t, if the move is well planned. The usual approach is a short overlap: your old 3PL keeps shipping from its remaining stock while the new warehouse receives and checks in yours. Orders switch over once stock is live and integrations are tested.

What should I check in my current 3PL contract before switching?

Look at your notice period, any exit or early termination fees, and the terms for releasing your stock. It’s also worth confirming you can export your order history, product data and stock records, so nothing is lost in the handover.

How does my stock get from my old 3PL to the new one?

Ask your old provider for a full stocktake report before stock is released, then have the new warehouse count and reconcile everything on arrival. Any discrepancies are much easier to resolve when both counts exist on paper.

What should I look for in a new 3PL?

If slow fulfilment and poor service are why you’re leaving, ask for numbers, not promises. Look for a clear dispatch cut-off time, an average pack time and an on-time fulfilment rate. At Plan A Logistics, that’s same-day dispatch for ecommerce orders received before 11am, a 3.5-hour average pack time and 99.8% of orders fulfilled on time. Also ask who you’ll actually speak to when something goes wrong, and how quickly they respond.

How quickly does Plan A Logistics ship orders?

Ecommerce orders received before 11am ship the same day. Orders received after 11am may also go out the same day, otherwise they ship the next business day. Wholesale and store replenishment orders are fulfilled within 24 hours, and returns are processed in under a day.

Will I lose control over my inventory?

No. A good 3PL gives you real-time visibility of stock levels and orders, often more than you had in-house.

Can a 3PL handle multiple sales channels?

Yes. Most 3PLs integrate with popular ecommerce platforms and marketplaces, so stock and orders stay in sync across every channel.

How many orders do you need before using a 3PL?

Every 3PL sets its own threshold. At Plan A Logistics, we work with brands shipping a minimum of 500 orders a week. Beyond the numbers, a good sign it’s time is whether fulfilment is limiting your growth or eating time you should spend elsewhere.

Is a 3PL more expensive than doing it yourself?

Not always. Once you factor in rent, wages, packaging, software, carrier rates and the cost of errors, in-house fulfilment is often more expensive than it looks. A 3PL also turns many fixed costs into variable ones.

Popular Searches Hide Popular Searches